Reader Response: Thank You For Your Service

Posted by

After finishing Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close by Jonathan Safran Foer, I felt brave enough to grab another emotional read from my ever-so-long-on-my-reading-list stack.

Thank You For Your Service by David Finkel has been in that stack for quite some time.

As a military spouse who has weathered my share of deployments, I just never quite know how this type of books will feel. I only know that this type of book is bound to hit close to home. I wonder. Will the book feel too optimistic? Too pessimistic? Too angry? Too trite? Will the author have laden everything with extra emotion and unnecessary melodrama? Because, seriously, there is really enough drama inherent in deployment and redeployment stories.

Thank You For Your Service was not optimistic or pessimistic, angry or trite. It was simply, overwhelmingly honest. Like, two boxes of tissues honest. Finkel tackles the people and their stories involved in this book eloquently, clearly, and with compassion. His writing is superb. He does not shy away from unflattering truth, but he nails an elegant balance in presenting the soldiers and the family members he covers as rich and complex people who are neither saints nor devils. Finkel presents the facts expertly and eloquently and then leaves the judgement calls up to the reader. The soldiers and families I spent the last two days reading about are so much like people I know. They are just people who are trying their best to cope with unimaginable and confusing feelings and situations.

Finkel isn’t telling every soldier’s story in this book, but he is telling stories that could potentially be about any soldier. Thank You For Your Service focuses on redeployment, PTSD, and people who were in situations that left them feeling broken. Finkel shines a light on some very personal and dark moments that people bravely shared with him. He also opens a small window for his reader to peek into the Army’s efforts to deal with these issues on a larger level, as of the writing of the book in October 2013, of course. For me, even when Finkel focuses on the big picture, he never allows us to lose sight of the individual stories that make up that picture.

Thank You For Your Service is a well crafted, personalized look at a topic that continues to deserve our attention.


Finkel has the following to say about the futility of making sense of it all:

The way it worked was that they joined the army because they were patriotic or starry-eyed or heartbroken or maybe just out of work, and then they were assigned to be in the infantry rather than something with better odds like finance or public affairs, and then by chance they were assigned to an infantry division that was about to rotate into the war, and then they were randomly assigned to a combat brigade that included two infantry battalions, one of which was going to a bad place and the other of which was going to a worse place, and then as luck would have it they were assigned to the battalion going to the worse place, and then they were assigned to the company in that battalion that went to the worst place of all. If you listen to the eulogies, so much of war is said to be accidental.(p. 51)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s